ERIN L. MCCOY

“OCCURRENCE OF A FOREIGN BAT IN ORKNEY”
After a paper by John Wolley, egg collector
and auk researcher, published in Zoologist
in 1849.
There is no explanation for loss. A shovel’s nose smacks the dirt. While digging potatoes, they caught a bat. Band of yellow hair.
On his first trip north, Wolley tracked sea eagles by the lamb-shaped gaps in flocks. A hundred years later, sheep were stamped with bright spots, hot pink or oyster blue or mauve on the haunch. No fear of eagles, long since wiped out.
No such bat lived in all of Scotland. A singularity is lonely; that is its defining fault.
Wolley became worried for the auk. Its shrunken wings were brilliant if observed through the plate glass of the sea’s surface, but on land— a failure of foresight.
Twelve years later, Wolley died at thirty-six. The consensus among the society of the Ibis journal is that his brain, like an egg, opened.
There is no explanation for a bird that once could fly and now cannot.
There was little wanting in him, wrote Alfred Newton after Wolley’s death. At the eagle’s reintroduction, sheep flocks fled along the upper slopes of the Orkneys and the Isle of Skye, where the clouds push so near you can stick out your tongue and taste a dozen kinds of snow. North enough that the crevice between heaven and earth is narrow. There’s no use for flight. Pieces of the closest planets used to break off and nest in the crown of the auk’s head.
| top |
*** ** ***
POST-ATLANTIC
after she escapes the sky, witch-auk drifts a long time on an empty atlantic. she washes ashore in new england, & i come to meet her there. down the boardwalk a team of gulls hacks up french fries & steamed clams. one is nutcracker-postured with an entire corndog down his throat; the stick flagpoles out his beak. but look,
the ocean always clung to its bounty. unpalatable fish float inert & crooked like boomerangs, the crabs oily in their mood-ring shells. & that there was once a wild-eyed captain who hunted a single whale for years
isn’t that impressive, when others made quicker work of the beasts. a clot of boys at the end of the dock smears us up & down with yellow eyes. they flick their kershaws open & shut. i let them crack me open, cut out & examine my organs one by one—no pearl, disappointment—toss them off the pier. witch-auk presses her cheek into my palm. when
will she find out about me? a drunk man toddles up to us, says his name is gary, tells us his story, how he’s leaving town after bedding a woman two feet taller than him & she’s become attached. shit happens, he says. go west.
we’ve read about it: a pacific raw & squirming, mussels caking every surface, & the scales of fish translucent with a grand inhuman light. i still believe that pain is a suit you can leave behind. i want to bleach my guts of me. so witch-auk and i decide to go together: toward forgetting.
witch-auk takes one last dip in the atlantic, shoots beneath the waves, & the bent fish wriggle back to life as she goes. i look over the railing at my reflection to wave goodbye. we haven’t seen each other in a long time. maybe someday she’ll be worth saving.
| top |
*** ** ***
WE’VE SEEN THE NEED FOR DISGUISES
in the changing room at the goodwill, witch-auk
will not make a decision. we’ve tried a lacy holiday
apron, horn-rimmed glasses (no lenses), a bow tie,
some mary jane pumps that (i should have predicted)
she can’t walk in without tripping, an egg-shaped
basket in which to carry—should she ever carry—
& of course a pointed halloween hat, although
she does not find this funny. in the end we leave
undisguised—which I know is a mistake.
who can see her beauty? out on the sidewalk
the passersby whistle & bump us, the cars slow
& honk, a skateboarder ogles mid-kickflip,
& the milkman in milk cap quits swinging his pail.
witch-auk stops in a puddle. she won’t budge.
the ripples expand from her feet. the water crests
& crests like she’s dropping through it. the world slows
around us as though viewed through syrup:
& reflected on their eyes’ curved planes
we are warped beings, though witch-auk shrugs
so what if we are. we ride the puddle all the way
to the river &, as we pass, all the petrified faces
look like tarnished crystal, like chipped goblets
or pennanted soldiers lining the pitch of our parade.
we catch the current, we drift off, we feel them waving.
| top |
*** ** ***
GREATEST
witch-auk & me sweat from our seams & sleep in our dreams & the trek has grown so exhausting that i don’t recall the last truck or the truck
before it, just that they’ve been mack trucks and this too’s a mack truck. witch-auk dangles her flippers over the stick shift
over rubber mats with bulldogs on them over the pinkish road rolled out over a hundred miles of colorado scrubland.
little use for flippers here. the driver starts the conversation with where you headed, like they all do.
he says he’s bound home, points to a photo adhered to the dash of a woman with feathered bangs, her hands on the shoulders of a small girl.
i say witch-auk has relatives in california—the greatest auk, miomancalla howardae (though when I told her this,
she didn’t want to hear). had relatives, i correct myself, many years ago. the driver laughs in a way that’s not glad, says i get it,
nods at the picture, she’s older now he says. witch-auk wants to ask how much older & i tell her that’s enough & keep quiet.
the driver twists at his beard with one hand on the wheel. the radio crackles into silence & he gets to humming & witch-auk
starts clacking her beak in counterpoint—like she knows the tune. he clicks the headlights on & we drive through the night like this—that song
in so many variations that i never can figure out how to join in. around four a.m., the driver starts crying, tears wiggling
down the wires of his beard. witch-auk leans against his arm. i have moved like a ghost across my own waking. through everyone i meet.
| top |
*** ** ***
WITCH-AUK & ME REACH THE PACIFIC
having spruced up our new
isle, plucked clear the beard
of its citadel, except for one
access—a basalt slope only
she & i know—witch-auk
snuggles down into a mound
of eelgrass & shells.
looks around herself.
like an egg is coming.
like it will arrive
from the outside, since
she has never in her life
seen how this works.
i have adorned
the slope’s bannisters:
feather-tongued barnacles,
tassels of bull kelp,
its hollow knobs filled
with sludge that glows
when you shake them,
which the sea does & does.
this ocean is an ever-
exhaling; bright foam
spits high into the cedars,
& the salt tastes pink
or like bubbles scooping
out a cetacean skull.
witch-auk shuts her eyes.
the waves stall.
with the sea gone
to glass, there is a way
that the clouds churn
below the water’s surface
that makes me understand
belief. i set out rowing,
search the whole sea.
the sun, paused in its
route, boils like a yolk.
i don’t know how long
we go on like this.
| top |
*** ** ***
POST-PACIFIC
look, witch-auk, whoever has ever
owned the whole sea, has made it tiny.
shallow in its skins of oil & cups.
slug-tongued with sunk hulls &
the drug of smearing warmth.
who has owned the whole sea
think they too own us—but they don’t,
do they? not the cotton-stuffed body of [],
killed on eldey & propped on a plank
in a brussels museum. not the body of []
out for cleaning at the smithsonian.
instead they showed me a shoebox of bones.
i didn’t want to tell you, but there’s nothing in me
you can’t reach. not the felt of new snow
that told me one winter to stop trying.
not that lunchroom table where i said too much
& never will again. not the bottle of cognac
a man whose name i’ve forgotten
brought to my door, & i let him
like i was a machine. but he doesn’t
have me. do you understand? nor
the ocean, whatever he calls it.
nor does the egg you never laid
deliver back into his grip. if you & i
came out not-quite-human, came out
monstrous, i still love the careful way
you nudge a blade of bull kelp
washed ashore in this last world
twisted to the shape of that last world.
this is ours—our disappointment.
also ours: how you place me whole
into the palm of my own hand.
| top |
ERIN L. MCCOY
Erin L. McCoy’s poetry collection, Wrecks, will be published by Noemi Press in 2025 and was a finalist for the Noemi Book Award. Her debut novel, Underlake, is forthcoming from Doubleday in 2026. Erin’s poetry and fiction have appeared in the American Poetry Review, Best New Poets, Pleiades, Conjunctions, and other publications, and she was a finalist for the Missouri Review’s Miller Audio Prize. She is an assistant poetry editor at Narrative and a proofreader at Penguin Random House. She holds an MFA in creative writing and an MA in Spanish and Latin American literature from the University of Washington. Her website is erinlmccoy.com.
To download a printable PDF version of this page, click here.
| top |